Child care subsidies would send 1.2 million women into the workforce, new paper finds


If child care subsidies like those proposed by the Biden administration were enacted — not the likeliest of scenarios at this point — a significant number of women would enter the job market, Emily writes.

Why it matters: Despite the policy’s slim chances, this is an important paper for the longer term analysis of the issue — likely the first quantitative look at how this type of proposal would affect maternal employment, the cost and quality of child care, and family incomes.

  • It also suggests a possible solution to the country’s stubbornly persistent labor shortage.

Details: The researchers, a team of eight economists who study child care and early education, modeled out the effects of the proposal in Biden’s Build Back Better plan — which would cap the amount families spend on child care, for children 5 and under, at no more than 7% of income for those earning up to 250% of median income.

  • Under the BBB scenario, the share of lower income mothers employed full time would increase by 18 percentage points; while overall there’d be a 10 point increase, amounting to 1.2 million moms.
  • Meanwhile, wages for child care work — one of the lowest paying sectors in the U.S. — would increase between 19%-29%, depending on the education level of the worker.
  • Finally, the researchers find that the increase in spending would enable more families to access higher-quality care. And it would reduce the amount of money most households pay out of pocket for care.

Zoom out: The U.S. lags most other high-income countries in terms of maternal employment.

  • In 2019, the most recent year for which data was available, 68% of mothers with children ages 3-5 were employed in the U.S., ranking the country 32nd on a list of 40.
  • The researchers estimate that broad child care support along the lines of the administration’s proposal would push the rate up to 78%, putting it in 9th place.

Between the lines: The public spends only $1,500 annually on children up until age five, according to a paper from last year. Then, when kids the enter k-12 system, that number shoots to $12,800.

  • Yet researchers have found support in the earliest years is critical to their development and well-being.
  • The country also benefits from a more educated and productive workforce in the long term, as I wrote in the New York Times last year.

The bottom line: At the moment, though, with inflation on everyone’s mind, this kind of fiscal spending seems far off.

Like it? Share with your friends!


What's Your Reaction?

hate hate
confused confused
fail fail
fun fun
geeky geeky
love love
lol lol
omg omg
win win


Leave a Reply